Volume I | Issue no. 4
In A Position To Achieve A Greater ROIThe Foundation for Successful Marketing Sometimes it’s hard for travel marketers to think of the value of a position in concrete ways. Similarly, it’s VERY hard for the C-Suite to justify staff resources and out of pocket expenses for positioning work if they can’t find immediate ways to demonstrate some semblance of an ROI. But if you look at a position as the foundation, just about every marketing initiative gets a bump in ROI. You are measuring ROI, aren’t you?When you dig down deep and get to the truth about your position, you’re really getting in touch with the soul of your business. If you’ve spent the time to learn about the soul of your company, and use it to position your brand, then lots of other things fall into place. Just think of front line staff. With an ethos to follow, they can really live the position, and create great consumer experiences. That may sound like an ethereal idea, but it’s very real, and it’s measurable.Brands that understand this consistently score better than the competitive set for customer satisfaction, advocacy (or willingness to recommend), and loyalty. Net promoter scores invariably rise. The correlation between these marketing metrics and good old dollars is strong. But, with no soul, it’s very hard to create a battle cry that the internal team can live by, and consumers will respond to. There are other good examples of how a strong position can make other marketing initiatives easier, and return more value. Consider internet marketingThis is a real-world, stone-cold example that EVERYONE has probably dealt with by now. If you haven’t, we expect that you will very shortly. In a down market, with media budgets on the chopping block, this is the one sector in the advertising industry that will see 15% growth in 2009. Without a solid brand position, the absolute basic web marketing 101 tasks like SEO and SEM are painful, and likely, aimless. Sure, it’s trackable, but without a position, creating effective paid and organic keyword campaigns that translate into conversions is difficult. With a unique position, creating long term strategies that improve organic rankings, deliver more relevant visitors, and convert at higher rates, is within reach. And remember the messagePerhaps the most compelling example of how much simpler marketing can become if a valid, meaningful position is established is in good old advertising and marketing communications. Consistently good creative is the love child of great positioning and creative talent. Agencies whose clients have established their competitive line in the sand, grounded in truthful insight, can deliver great work over and over. It also makes it easy to stay on track over time. How many times have we seen marketing campaigns lose the mojo after a few great executions, and then completely unravel after a few quarters? Positioning can help avoid this, and help ensure that good decisions are made over time. | ||
what you are talking about can be said in one word authenticity -we all are looking for what is real about where we go - what is part of the culture - what the locals do - why they live here - not the same starbucks on every corner - what is real about where we are - we do not leave home to find home - not real travelers!! Tourists leave home to find home and want whats familiar - real travelers seek authenticity -we want to experience something very different from our usual day to day.
Authenticity is indeed what many travelers are looking for, but authenticity is a difficult concept to market and monetize. In marketing, "authenticity" has become a cliché -- much like the word "unique". If every destination is about "authenticity", authenticity becomes a commodity. And while your point about this difference between "real" travelers and tourists is interesting, most destinations need to appeal to both to have sustainable tourism business.
Some good advice there. Working with operators and regional tourism offices in New Zealand, it's frustratingly obvious that some are the need to design a clear image, more then ignore their strategic marketing plans and many lack allegiance to their own brand image. When we deliver PR and e-marketing for out tourism clients it's essential to keep inline with greater brand objectives.
Tourist may want familiar, and travelers may want authentic, but as a "lodging provider" we want them both. How then to market to both effectively is the question? Can we do both? Yes - if your destination and experience provide both. If it doesn't, then one must choose to market to the segment they can satisfy. It's just as important to know what you aren't as what you are. So if you are in a suburban 'hood near Disney that's cheap and big - that's ok, just as if it's ok if you are in a funky downtown loft in NYC...
I enjoyed this article and the comments; yes I agree with "authenticity". But what about emphasizing the "cultural" aspect of the destination? For instance, I live on Maui, HI and I am working on incorporating information about the Hawaiian culture on my travel site; same thing with the other destinations in the South Pacific; people are interested in learning about different cultures and how they can experience them, teach their kids and have travel stories to take home to share with friends.
first time to visit wanderlust but i am impressed by the content.
let me understand it further
info@worldhoteldirectory.us
Cultural aspects of a destination are important in defining a positioning. However, its important to remember that a destination's culture is merely a feature and that many destinations have culture to offer. Consumers ultimately want to know what the experience will be like (how will it be different than any other location) and how will it make me feel (meaningful high order benefit). When you can define and articulate these, you have the building blocks of a unique positioning.
Social Influence is of greater importance than most items you mentioned. Branding is shrinking as influence is growing. Influence the Influencers. It's not just friends now -- it's friendsters.
Simon and Okia, thanks for the comments.
Todd, I think you are confusing the idea of branding with the practice of mass media advertising. They are not interchangeable. Advertising is one tactic used in branding, sociaI influence is another. I agree with you that social influence is growing in importance and that influencing the influencers is becoming more important every day — due to the growth in online social networking. But to say that positive social influencers aren't practicing brand advocacy would be inaccurate. They may not view themselves as participants in the branding process, but they are nevertheless. Since a brand has always been what consumers think it is and not always what a company wants it to be, social influence is the purest form of branding.
Talking about positionning is from the very past of marketing. It talks to the "reason side" of the consumer and help him to make its own conclusion. But conclusion won' t make him act. "While reason drives you to conclusions, emotions drive you to act". The way to market any product is to think on relations with consumer. And make that relation based on love. Tourism is the best, the most complicated and the most exciting category to manage. Almost every place can introduce a love relationship.
Vincent,it is true that in the past (and unfortunately the present) marketers have tried to position brands to appeal to the "reason side." If you take another read of this newsletter and poke around our site, you'll find that we are proponents of positioning to appeal to the emotional side of the consumer. Appealing to reason is not, nor has ever been a sustainable as a point of differentiation.
Some solid info...needs time to take it all in...am trying hard! tony
Quote: "Once that truth has been uncovered and clearly articulated, every decision that has to be made gets a lot easier moving forward".
That's just where the problems come in for tourist destinations which still have to be discovered. In our experience here in South Africa it seems that the majority of (inbound) tour operators are not very much into exploration of new destinations. They choose the safe 'mainstream' destinations ......
Despite economic recession and the impact of this on the tourism industry we offer since a few years together with a few partners package deals; mainly via direct marketing towards our target markets. Result: 50% increase in bookings in comparison with last year. Majority via direct (online) bookings. The travel industry in South Africa did not see the potential of our idea when we started it. Now we are branding the Klaas Voogds area in the Western Cape as the only 'self sufficient' destination between Cape Town and Garden Route; the best (hand crafted) wine from the Robertson Wine Valley are "original Klaas Voogds", there is a game drive with only indigenous game (no zoo Big 5), two of the best restaurants plus private dining, a nature reserve, 4x4 track, angling spots, massages, the world's largest hedge maze, unique succulent gardens, olive tasting, taxidermist demonstrations, wire art, woodwork, candle making, etc. etc.
And guests are spreading the word at home never to book an organised trip to South Africa but to go on a self discovery tour instead of being guided from one tourist trap into another ....
Branding is useful but it can work against you when tourists find out that they are fooled .....
We choose very concious for long term branding with integrity! This pays off at the end.
P.S. I also noticed that you're Google ranking for all of the page titles used in this article is pretty close to perfect. Nice job.