In This Issue:Rethinking Outdated Travel Media Strategies
Need Assistance?Call us at 888-754-3210Or Email us
|
Volume II | Issue no. 4
Rethinking Outdated Travel Media StrategiesTravel and tourism marketers find it’s no longer practical to give mass media the highest priority in integrated marketing communications programs. It’s time to rethink outdated media strategies and leverage ‘owned’ media first, for more effective communications, greater consumer engagement and a higher return on investment. This Wanderlust Report examines the trends that have reshaped the media environment and the opportunities that new media channels present.
Destination marketers must evolve their communication strategiesSixty years ago, the travel and tourism advertising model was relatively simple: Come up with a single creative idea and send it to as many people as possible, as efficiently as possible. It was all about broadcasting – spending a lot of money to get a few ideas to a lot of people – and eliciting enough response to justify your investment. The metrics were reach, frequency and gross impressions; a simple numbers game that relied on efficiency to deliver visitors to their destinations, resorts and attractions. Of course, sixty years ago media selection was simpler. The small number of choices made it simpler. Even speaking to consumers was simpler (compared to the sophisticated, advertising-savvy audience of today). But it’s a different world now, and in the increasingly complex media realm of the 21st century, the old way simply doesn’t work anymore. Fast forward to the present state of the mediaToday, media fragmentation and changing consumer habits are forcing us to rethink how we allocate our marketing dollars. It’s imperative that DMOs, CVBs, resorts and attractions that once relied on paid mass media exposure and the efficiency of their buy figure out the best way of leveraging ‘owned’ media to communicate more effectively. Instead of starting with high-priced, low-return campaigns in paid, interruptive mass media, we’re investing in the destination experience first and exploring lower-cost, higher return engagements with small, segmented audiences that are open to dialog. Just as the media strategy must change, messaging strategies must also adapt. No longer is it as easy as having one brand position - one message - one audience. Now destinations must have one brand position that can be expressed in many relevant ways that are appropriate to a variety of smaller, diverse audiences. | |
Mark,
Great article. Just wanted to let you know that I quoted your point about "narrowcasting" in the comments thread for the article I published yesterday about measurement. I'd just read this when I received that comment and it was the perfect response.
Also, I like the hierarchy of media effectiveness diagram. It does a great job conveying a lot of information in a very simple way, but especially in that it shows how proportionately few "actual experiences" are leveraged in marketing--they occupy the tip of the pyramid (the smallest space), but they have the most impact. Very true.
Chris
Chris,
Thanks for the kudos. And thanks for the quote. Only wish I was the author. Alan Beberwyck, our chief wordsmith, crafted this month's Wanderlust Report. (I am far from the only person who adds value here at Wanderlust) I did send him in search of the concept of owned -> earned -> paid media, partly because I was swamped with client work - and partly so I'm not the only one here thinking in these terms. He did a spectacular job capturing the essence of what I wanted to communicate without groaning that I dropped this rock on his desk. (thanks again, Alan, for stepping up)
As for the Hierarchy chart, I saw something similar in a presentation given by Tim Williams recently. Not sure where he got it. We've been practicing the concepts behind it for nearly a decade but had never seen it communicated so simply. We adapted it for the Travel & Leisure industry and posted it here. Happy you found it as concise and as informative as we did.
Mark,
Thanks for letting me know. I apologize for assuming! Alan, great article!
Chris
Chris/Mark: Thanks for the kind words. I can't take all the credit for the ideas behind the article, but I'm happy that our newsletter can open a discussion on such an important issue for the travel marketing industry.
Great article. Have shared it widely around my network. I am going to use the charts in my lectures (quoted off course)
Keep it up!
Thanks/Claus
Great article, going to be sharing it quite a bit. I totally agree with the information. We see the value of creating destination & theme based content/websites to drive visitors. This actually is what our new marketing platform does (as well as the SEO & social media etc.)
Thanks for sharing!
John SGT Slaughter.
Mark, great article and some very interesting points to consider. It is interesting to note how the technologies that we all seem to fall in love with and expect huge benefits from seem to complicate our lives in unexpected ways. The evolution will continue to force marketers to think more like publishers and content providers and less and less like strategic brand managers.
Interesting article. I agree that DMO's must be client oriented in their marketing and give a central place to theme based content/websites to drive visitors. Unique content gives a good ranking in searchengines (SEO). I'm absolutely NOT sure what the effectiviness of Social Media could be at the end. I'm participating in some platforms as Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter etc. My statistics see very few visitors coming to my websites through these channels. Twitter a hype??? Who knows?
Rene Husken
Claus - Thanks for the good words and by all means, share the charts.
John S - Thanks for the comments and thanks for connecting. It's great to speak with like minds in the industry.
John C - technology does have a double edge sword. I remember when the fax machine first, followed soon after by Fedex sped up the world, and at the same time, reduced the amount of thinking time we all have. And yes, marketers will have to have substance behind their efforts. In the old days, you could get away with making it look good. Today, that is all but a thing of the past.
René - Social media is an enigma and major time suck in its current form. While there are certainly examples of success, I suspect the overall effort being exerted presently is far greater than the ROI. But, there has most certainly been a major shift in the way consumers of just about any category are viewing marketing. Engagement, whether its by poking their minds (the old way) or by interacting (the new way) is the present rule of the day.
Recently we launched a 2.0 version of a blog for a private island development project in the Caribbean, tcsportingclub.com/blog . The 1.0 version was a highly successful engagement based strategy that communicated real, authentic content to a highly private group of wealthy owners. The results were astounding from an analytics, viral and lead generation perspective. The 2.0 version leveraged the insights gained from the analytics, quantitative and qualitative data to drive even deeper engagement to this group. Unfortunately most brands today really miss this point, conventional marketing strategies don't work unless you are prepared to drive massive numbers of impressions, which most hotels & resorts lack the resources to effectively sustain. As a result case studies like this have much more validity to a sustainable and effective hotel or resort marketing strategy.
Really appreciated the article. Having lead marketing and sales teams at some of the major attractions in Southern California, I have experienced first-hand the power of the trifecta of word-of-mouth/experience/relationship.
I agree. Having a strong relationship with a customer, and knowledge of the quality products always gives brings me a word of mouth recommendation, and another valuable and grateful customer.
Best explanation of what is happening around us as it relates to marketing I have read. I love the "owned media" phrase. Great Job
Excellent article, and explanation of the shifting landscape of tourism marketing. I love the terms "owned", "earned" and "paid" media. Spot on. The "owned" and "earned" media capabilities level the playing field and allow smaller DMOs/CVBs/properties to compete with their larger counterparts. Keep up the good work.
Word-of-Mouth is massively important in travel decisions but I would also argue that you need both efficiency and effectiveness in your communications to achieve your business objectives.
There is so much competition now in Tourism that the right message has to hit the largest possible target audience as quickly, efficiently and accurately as possible. Word of mouth is immensely powerful but one needs the reassurance of other sources of marketing communications to establish the credibility of a business in travel/tourism.